There is nothing more comforting than a warm chicken pot pie. It feels like home. The Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipe is rich, creamy, and full of flavor, and it is perfect for family dinners on cold evenings. The golden crust. The creamy filling. Every bite feels special. This guide covers the Martha Stewart chicken pot pie recipe in full depth, from the exact ingredients and the twelve-step method to variations, what to serve with it, and how to store the leftovers.
If you have ever needed a winter dinner that feeds a family, uses up leftover chicken or turkey, and fills the house with the smell of butter and herbs, this is the one. The prep takes about twenty-five minutes, the bake takes thirty to thirty-five minutes, and the whole pie is ready in about sixty minutes. It serves six people at about 450 calories each, and it uses only fourteen simple ingredients. Follow the steps below and you will get a golden, flaky crust over a thick, creamy filling that slices cleanly at the table.
For more cozy winter dinners, see our Easy Beef Stew for Winter Nights.
The full original recipe this guide is based on is the Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipe, with the same ingredients, times, and method used below.
Why Chicken Pot Pie Belongs on the Winter Table
Winter cooking asks a lot of the cook. There is a cold evening to warm up, a family to feed, and a dinner that needs to feel special without keeping you at the stove all night. Chicken pot pie fits that moment perfectly. It is a whole meal in one dish: chicken, carrots, potatoes, and peas in a creamy sauce, all under a golden crust. You make the filling in one skillet, pour it into a pie dish, cover it with pastry, and the oven does the rest. While it bakes, you are free to set the table and welcome everyone in from the cold.
It also solves the most common problem with winter cooking: leftovers. The recipe uses two cups of cooked chicken breast, shredded, and it works just as well with leftover turkey, which makes it a natural meal for the days after Thanksgiving or Christmas. The original recipe says so itself: turkey is an easy swap, the flavor stays delicious, and it is a great way to use holiday leftovers and avoid waste.
Chicken pot pie also suits every kind of winter evening. It works for a family Sunday dinner, a holiday gathering, a potluck party, a comfort food night, or a thoughtful meal for someone who needs comfort. The original recipe lists all of these occasions, and it is right: a golden pie coming out of the oven is the kind of food that makes people slow down and sit together. Make it once and it may become the Sunday dinner your family asks for every winter, though there are rarely many leftovers with this one.
There is something else that makes this dish special: it tastes like effort without taking much of it. The sauce is butter, flour, broth, and milk, cooked slowly until thick. The vegetables are boiled for eight minutes and finished in the pie. The crust is two ready-made pie crusts, so there is no pastry to make from scratch. That is exactly the feeling a winter dinner is meant to have: warm, generous, and unhurried.
What Makes This Chicken Pot Pie So Good
The first thing you notice about this chicken pot pie is the contrast. The top crust turns golden brown and flaky in the oven, while the filling underneath stays creamy, thick, and full of tender chicken and vegetables. Then comes the flavor: butter and thyme in the sauce, sweet carrots and peas, soft potatoes, and fresh parsley stirred through at the end. The contrast between the crisp crust and the soft, creamy filling is what makes people reach for a second slice.
The flavor is rich without being heavy. The sauce is made the right way, with butter and flour cooked slowly and warm broth whisked in, so it coats every piece of chicken and vegetable without turning gluey. The milk adds creaminess, the thyme adds a warm herbal note, and the parsley at the end adds a bright, fresh flavor. A pinch of salt and half a teaspoon of black pepper season the whole pie, and the beaten egg brushed on top gives the crust its shine.
The recipe is also forgiving, which matters when you are cooking on a busy winter evening. The steps are simple, the ingredients are few, and the bake gives you a clear visual signal: a golden brown crust with the filling bubbling slightly through the slits means the pie is done. Even if your chicken is a little drier or your vegetables a little firmer than expected, the creamy sauce covers it. That is the mark of a good comfort recipe: it works even when the kitchen is crowded and the cook is in a hurry.
Why You Should Never Rush the Sauce
This is the secret the original recipe states plainly, and it is the one detail that decides whether the pie is creamy or disappointing. The secret is simple: do not rush the sauce. Cook the butter and flour slowly, because that makes a smooth base. Add warm broth, not cold, because that keeps the sauce creamy.
Here is why it works. When you melt the butter and stir in the flour, you are making a roux, and the flour needs about two minutes of gentle cooking to lose its raw taste. If you rush this step, the sauce tastes floury. If you cook it too fast or too hot, the flour browns and the sauce turns dark and nutty instead of pale and creamy. Two minutes over medium heat, stirring well, is exactly right.
The broth matters just as much. Warm broth blends into the hot roux smoothly, while cold broth shocks it and makes lumps. The original recipe says to pour the warm broth in slowly and whisk gently until the sauce is smooth and thick, and then to pour in the milk while stirring, cooking for five minutes until the sauce is thick and creamy. Stir often so it does not stick. That patience is the whole recipe: a smooth sauce coats the chicken and vegetables, while a rushed sauce turns thin, lumpy, or floury.
The other part of the secret is the rest. The recipe says to let the pie rest for ten minutes before slicing, and to let the filling cool slightly before adding it to the crust. A rested pie slices cleanly because the sauce has thickened as it cools. Cut it too soon and the filling runs. Give it ten minutes and every slice holds its shape.
Ingredients You Will Need
This recipe serves six people, and the ingredients below are exactly the ones in the original Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipe. They are all pantry and fridge staples, which is why this is such a good winter dinner.
- 2 cups cooked chicken breast, shredded
- 1 cup carrots, diced
- 1 cup frozen peas
- 1 cup potatoes, peeled and diced small
- 1/3 cup unsalted butter
- 1/3 cup all-purpose flour
- 2 cups chicken broth
- 1 cup whole milk
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
- 1/2 teaspoon dried thyme
- 1 tablespoon fresh parsley, chopped
- 2 pie crusts (top and bottom)
- 1 egg, beaten (for brushing)
A few notes on the ingredients will help you get the best result. Use cooked chicken breast, shredded, because it mixes evenly through the sauce and gives every slice the same amount of chicken. Leftover roast chicken works well, and rotisserie chicken is the fastest option of all: the recipe’s own tips recommend it for faster prep. Dice the potatoes small, as the recipe says, so they cook through in the eight-minute boil and finish tender inside the pie. Large chunks stay hard in the middle.
Use whole milk, not skimmed, because the fat in whole milk keeps the sauce rich and creamy. Use warm chicken broth, not cold, for the reason above: warm broth keeps the sauce smooth. And use fresh parsley if you can: the recipe’s secret section says fresh herbs give a bright flavor, and the parsley is stirred in at the end so it stays green and fresh. Dried thyme is fine for the sauce, but fresh thyme works too if you have it.
Equipment You Will Need
You do not need any special equipment for chicken pot pie. The original recipe uses a large skillet, a medium saucepan, a wooden spoon, a whisk, measuring cups and spoons, a knife, a cutting board, a 9-inch pie dish, a rolling pin, a pastry brush, and an oven, and that is all it takes.
- Large skillet, for the creamy sauce and filling
- Medium saucepan, for boiling the carrots and potatoes
- Wooden spoon, for stirring the sauce
- Whisk, for smoothing the broth into the roux
- Measuring cups and spoons, for the butter, flour, broth, and milk
- Knife, for dicing the carrots and potatoes
- Cutting board, for prep
- 9-inch pie dish, for baking the pie
- Rolling pin, for shaping the crust if needed
- Pastry brush, for the beaten egg wash
- Oven, for baking the pie
A few notes on the equipment will help. A 9-inch pie dish is the size the recipe is written for: a smaller dish will overflow, and a larger dish will spread the filling too thin. A whisk is the right tool for the sauce, because it breaks up lumps as the broth goes in, while a wooden spoon is better for the gentle stirring once the filling is mixed. The pastry brush matters more than it looks: a thin, even layer of beaten egg is what gives the top crust its golden shine, and a brush spreads it far more evenly than a spoon.
How to Make Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie
Follow these twelve steps in order and the pie will come out golden on top with a thick, creamy filling every time. The steps follow the original recipe exactly, with the broth and milk additions split out as their own steps and the preheat, egg wash, bake, and rest each given their own step, so nothing is rushed.
- Step 1: Cook the vegetables. Place the diced carrots and potatoes in a small pot, cover with water, and boil for about eight minutes until slightly tender. Drain and set aside. Do not overcook them: they will cook more inside the pie, and overcooked vegetables turn to mush in the filling.
- Step 2: Melt the butter and add the flour. In a large skillet, melt the third of a cup of butter over medium heat. Add the third of a cup of flour slowly and stir well for two minutes. This removes the raw taste of the flour and makes a smooth base. Keep the heat at medium and stir the whole time so the flour does not brown.
- Step 3: Slowly pour in the warm chicken broth. Pour the two cups of warm chicken broth in a little at a time, whisking gently as you go, until the sauce is smooth and thick. Warm broth, not cold, is the key: it blends into the hot roux without lumps. If the sauce looks lumpy, keep whisking gently and it will smooth out.
- Step 4: Add the milk and seasoning. Pour in the cup of whole milk while stirring, then add the teaspoon of salt, the half teaspoon of black pepper, and the half teaspoon of dried thyme. Cook for five minutes, stirring often so the sauce does not stick. The sauce should be thick and creamy, coating the back of a spoon.
- Step 5: Mix the filling. Add the two cups of shredded cooked chicken, the boiled carrots and potatoes, the cup of frozen peas, and the tablespoon of chopped fresh parsley. Stir gently until everything is coated in the sauce. Turn off the heat and let the filling cool slightly before adding it to the crust. A hot filling steams the bottom crust and makes it soggy.
- Step 6: Preheat the oven and prepare the bottom crust. Preheat your oven to 400°F (200°C). Place one pie crust into your 9-inch pie dish and press it gently into the sides. Trim any extra dough around the edges if needed. The crust should sit flat against the dish with no air pockets underneath.
- Step 7: Fill the pie. Pour the creamy chicken mixture into the crust and spread it evenly. Do not overfill: leave a little space at the top so the filling does not bubble over the edges while it bakes.
- Step 8: Add the top crust. Place the second crust over the filling and pinch the edges together to seal. Cut small slits on top: this allows steam to escape while the pie bakes, so the crust stays crisp instead of puffing up and cracking.
- Step 9: Brush the top crust with beaten egg. Brush the beaten egg evenly over the top crust with a pastry brush. This is what makes the crust golden and shiny, so cover the whole surface and get into the pinched edges too.
- Step 10: Bake for 30 to 35 minutes. Put the pie in the middle of the oven and bake until the crust is golden brown and the filling bubbles slightly through the slits. If the top browns too fast, cover it loosely with foil and keep baking until the filling bubbles.
- Step 11: Rest the pie for 10 minutes before slicing. Take the pie out of the oven and let it rest for ten minutes. The sauce thickens as it cools, so a rested pie slices cleanly and holds its shape. Cut it too soon and the filling runs across the plate.
- Step 12: Slice and serve. Cut the pie into six slices with a sharp knife and serve warm. Each slice should show the golden crust, the creamy filling, and the chicken and vegetables inside. Serve it straight from the pie dish at the table for the full comfort-food effect.
Tips for Perfect Chicken Pot Pie Every Time
These six tips come from the original recipe, and they are the difference between a good pie and a great one.
First, use rotisserie chicken for faster prep. A store-bought rotisserie chicken shreds easily and is already seasoned, so it saves the time of cooking and shredding chicken breasts. It is the fastest way to get this pie on the table on a busy evening.
Second, add corn for extra sweetness. A handful of corn kernels stirred in with the peas adds sweet pops that balance the savory sauce. Frozen corn works fine: add it at the same time as the peas.
Third, try puff pastry instead of regular pie crust. Puff pastry bakes up taller, flakier, and more golden than a standard pie crust, and it turns the pie into something that feels a little more special. Use it for the top crust only, and keep the regular crust on the bottom so the pie holds together.
Fourth, add a pinch of garlic powder for more flavor. Garlic powder stirred into the sauce with the salt and pepper deepens the savory flavor without changing the texture. A pinch is enough: the thyme and parsley should still be the herbs you taste.
Fifth, use fresh thyme instead of dried if available. Fresh thyme gives a brighter, greener flavor than dried, and the recipe’s own secret section says fresh herbs give a bright flavor. Strip the leaves from the stems and use the same amount.
Sixth, let the pie rest before serving. This tip appears twice in the original recipe, in the secret section and in the tips, because it matters that much. Ten minutes of rest lets the sauce thicken and the slices hold their shape. It is the easiest step to skip and the one you will notice most if you do.
Variations to Try
Once you have baked the classic version, these variations use the same sauce and the same method, so they are easy to try.
Leftover turkey pot pie: replace the two cups of chicken with two cups of leftover turkey. The original recipe’s own FAQ says this works easily and the flavor stays delicious, and it is a great way to use holiday leftovers and avoid waste. Use dark and light meat mixed for the best flavor, and keep everything else the same.
Corn and mushroom pot pie: add a cup of sliced mushrooms and half a cup of corn with the vegetables. The original FAQ says you can add mushrooms, green beans, or corn, and to cook hard vegetables first so they become tender inside the pie. Sauté the mushrooms for a few minutes before adding them, so they do not water down the sauce.
Puff pastry chicken pot pie: use puff pastry for the top crust instead of a second pie crust. The puff pastry rises high and turns deeply golden, and it makes the pie look like it came from a bakery. Brush it with the beaten egg and bake for the same thirty to thirty-five minutes.
Individual chicken pot pies: divide the filling between four small oven-safe dishes and top each one with a round of pie crust. Bake for twenty-five to thirty minutes, since the smaller pies cook faster. These are perfect for a potluck or for a family where everyone wants their own pie.
Spicy chicken pot pie: add a pinch of chili flakes or a dash of hot sauce to the sauce with the salt and pepper. The heat wakes up the creamy sauce without overwhelming it, and it pairs well with the sweet peas and carrots.
For another creamy winter soup to serve alongside this pie, our Easy Potato Soup for Winter Nights is a classic in the same style. And for a second cozy main on the same winter table, the Easy White Chicken Chili for Winter Nights brings Joanna Gaines’s creamy chili to the menu.
What to Serve with Chicken Pot Pie
Chicken pot pie is rich and creamy, so it pairs best with light sides. The original recipe suggests a fresh green salad, a simple cucumber salad, garlic bread, apple pie, and vanilla pudding, and each one works for a different moment.
A fresh green salad is the lightest pairing. The crisp leaves and a sharp vinaigrette cut through the richness of the pie and refresh the palate between bites. Keep the dressing simple: lemon and olive oil is enough.
A simple cucumber salad works the same way. Cool, crisp cucumber with a little vinegar is the contrast a creamy pie needs, and it takes five minutes to make while the pie rests.
Garlic bread is the comfort pairing. Warm, buttery garlic bread is perfect for scooping up any sauce that escapes the slice, and it keeps the meal firmly in comfort-food territory. Serve it warm from the oven alongside the pie.
For dessert, the original recipe suggests apple pie or vanilla pudding. Keep it simple and comforting: a slice of apple pie with the same golden crust as the main course, or a bowl of vanilla pudding that needs no effort at all. For a warm soup to start the meal, the Easy Christmas Soup Recipes for a Cozy Holiday Night has options that lead into the pie nicely. And for a hearty side that fills the table, the Easy Mashed Potatoes for Thanksgiving are creamy enough to sit next to the pie without competing with it.
Make-Ahead and Storage
This pie is easy to plan ahead, which is why it suits busy winter evenings so well.
The filling can be made one day before. The original recipe’s own FAQ says you can prepare the filling one day before and store it in the fridge, then assemble and bake the next day for the best texture and freshness. Make the filling through step five, cool it, cover it, and refrigerate. The next day, bring it back to room temperature for a few minutes, fill the crust, and bake as usual.
Leftovers keep well in the fridge. Store leftovers in the fridge for up to three days, covered tightly with foil or plastic wrap. Covering matters: an uncovered slice dries out and the crust goes soft in the fridge air.
Reheat in the oven, not the microwave. Reheat in the oven at 350°F for fifteen minutes. The original recipe says to avoid microwaving if possible, because it softens the crust. The oven keeps the crust crisp and warms the filling through evenly.
You can also freeze the baked pie. The original recipe says you can freeze a baked pie for up to two months. Cool it completely, wrap it tightly in foil and then in a freezer bag, and thaw it in the fridge overnight before reheating in the oven at 350°F until hot through.
Nutrition at a Glance
Each serving of this chicken pot pie has 450 calories, with 24 grams of protein, 25 grams of fat, 35 grams of carbohydrate, 3 grams of fiber, and 620 milligrams of sodium. The pie serves six people, so those numbers are per slice.
What the numbers tell you is that this is a filling, complete meal in one slice. The 24 grams of protein come mostly from the chicken and the milk, and they are what make the pie satisfying. The 35 grams of carbohydrate come from the crust, the potatoes, and the flour in the sauce, and they are what make it feel like comfort food. The 620 milligrams of sodium is the number to watch if you are cutting back on salt: most of it comes from the salt in the sauce and the broth, so a low-sodium chicken broth is the easiest way to bring it down without changing the flavor much.
If you want a lighter version, use low-fat milk instead of whole milk and a low-sodium broth, and go lighter on the butter in the roux. The pie will still be creamy, because the flour thickens the sauce whatever milk you use. Adding more vegetables, like the mushrooms, green beans, or corn the recipe suggests, stretches the filling further and adds fiber without adding many calories.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use leftover turkey instead of chicken?
Yes. The original recipe’s own FAQ says you can easily replace the chicken with turkey, and the flavor will still be delicious. It is a great way to use holiday leftovers and avoid waste. Use two cups of leftover turkey, shredded, in place of the two cups of chicken, and keep everything else the same. Dark meat turkey is especially good here, because it stays moist in the sauce.
How do I keep the bottom crust from getting soggy?
Make sure the filling is not too watery, and let it cool slightly before adding it to the crust. Those are the original recipe’s own answers. A filling that goes in hot steams the bottom crust from below, so the cooling step matters. You can also bake the bottom crust for five minutes before filling it, which sets the pastry and gives it a head start against the moisture.
Can I make this recipe ahead of time?
Yes. The original recipe’s own FAQ says you can prepare the filling one day before, store it in the fridge, and assemble and bake the next day for the best texture and freshness. Make the filling through step five, cool it, and cover it tightly. Do not assemble the pie the day before: a filled, unbaked pie sitting overnight makes the bottom crust soggy.
What vegetables can I add?
You can add mushrooms, green beans, or corn, as the original recipe’s own FAQ says. Just make sure to cook hard vegetables first so they become tender inside the pie. Boil green beans with the carrots and potatoes, sauté mushrooms for a few minutes before adding them, and add corn at the same time as the peas. Do not add raw hard vegetables straight to the filling, or they will still be crunchy when the pie is done.
How do I know when the pie is fully cooked?
The crust should be golden brown, and the filling should bubble slightly through the slits. Those are the original recipe’s own signs. If the top browns too fast, cover it loosely with foil and keep baking until the filling bubbles. The bake takes thirty to thirty-five minutes at 400°F, and the bubbling is the sign the filling is hot all the way through.
Can I use rotisserie chicken instead of cooked chicken breast?
Yes. The original recipe’s own tips recommend rotisserie chicken for faster prep. A store-bought rotisserie chicken shreds easily and is already seasoned, so it saves the time of cooking and shredding chicken breasts. Use two cups of shredded meat, and pick out any skin and bones before adding it to the sauce.
Final Thoughts
The Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipe is pure comfort food. It is creamy, warm, and satisfying. Now you know how to make Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipe step by step, and the ingredients are simple and easy to find.
This is the pie to make when the evenings turn cold and the family gathers around the table. The golden crust, the creamy filling, and the smell of butter and thyme are the whole point of winter cooking. For another winter main to cook the following week, the Easy Turkey Chili for the Holidays brings a lighter, spicier comfort dish to the table, and the Easy Winter Corn Chowder Recipes for Cozy Family Dinners and the Easy Winter Meatloaf Recipes for Cozy Family Dinners round out a full winter menu.















Leave a Reply